The 2024 Smart #1 and #3 mark the brand's return to Australia with a focus on electric small SUVs. While they impress with their performance, technology, and distinctive styling, some may find the limited dealer network and quirky features challenging.
7.6/10
CarExplore Overall Comparative Score
This score is based on the rating provided by Drive, as Chasing Cars did not provide a numerical rating.
Quick Facts
- Price Range: $54,900 - $70,900 (plus on-road costs)
- ANCAP Safety Rating: Not yet rated (5-star Euro NCAP rating)
- Electric Range: Up to 455km (WLTP)
- Charging: Up to 150kW DC fast charging
Key Specifications
| Specification | Details |
|---|---|
| Motor | Single or dual electric motors |
| Power | 200kW (single motor), 315kW (dual motor) |
| Torque | 343Nm (single motor), 584Nm (dual motor) |
| Transmission | Single-speed automatic |
| Drive Type | Rear-wheel drive or all-wheel drive |
| 0-100km/h | 6.7 seconds (single motor), 3.7-3.9 seconds (dual motor) |
| Battery | 66kWh |
| Boot Space | 323-411L (depending on model) |
Performance and Driving Experience
- Impressive acceleration, especially in Brabus models
- Comfortable ride quality in urban environments
- Multiple driving modes available
- Some body roll noted in corners
- Quiet and refined cabin environment
Expert Insight: "The #3's handling and response feels marginally more tied-down and controlled than the #1, but neither disgraces itself." - Chasing Cars
Charging and Efficiency
- Up to 455km range on WLTP cycle
- DC fast charging up to 150kW
- 10-80% charge in approximately 30 minutes
- Energy consumption between 16.8-18.2kWh/100km (claimed)
Value for Money
- Competitive pricing against established luxury EV rivals
- Well-equipped with modern technology and safety features
- Five-year/150,000km warranty
Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Strong performance, especially in Brabus models
- Distinctive styling with Mercedes-Benz influences
- Advanced technology features
- Comfortable and well-designed interior
Cons:
- Limited dealer network (only three locations in Australia)
- Some quirky features may not appeal to all buyers
- Smaller boot space compared to some rivals
- No sliding rear seat in #3 model
Expert Review Summaries
Chasing Cars
Rating: Not provided
- Pros:
- Engaging driving dynamics
- Premium interior feel
- Strong performance
- Cons:
- Limited dealer network
- Some ergonomic issues
Summary: "The #1 and #3 are the 'smart' size choice for our market addicted to small SUVs, but there's something that's been lost: the old Smart's innovation and dare-to-be-different attitude." Read the full review
Drive
Rating: 7.6/10
- Pros:
- Impressive performance
- High-quality interior
- Advanced technology
- Cons:
- Limited availability
- Some quirky features
Summary: "The Smart #1 is a compelling new entrant in the small electric SUV segment, offering strong performance and premium features at a competitive price point." Read the full review
CarExplore's Take on the 2024 Smart #1 and #3
The 2024 Smart #1 and #3 represent an interesting return for the brand to the Australian market, now focusing on electric small SUVs. These models offer a blend of performance, technology, and distinctive styling that sets them apart in the growing electric vehicle segment.
Both the #1 and #3 impress with their acceleration, particularly in the Brabus variants which offer supercar-like 0-100km/h times. The interior quality and technology features are noteworthy, with clear Mercedes-Benz influences adding a premium feel.
However, potential buyers should be aware of some limitations. The dealer network is currently restricted to just three locations in Australia, which may pose challenges for servicing and support. Some of the quirky features, like the animal avatar "travel companion," may not appeal to all buyers and could be seen as unnecessary distractions.
Ideal For: Urban dwellers looking for a stylish, high-performance electric SUV with premium features, who live near the limited dealer network and appreciate unique design elements.
Consider Alternatives If: You need a more extensive dealer network, prefer more conventional features, or require maximum practicality in terms of boot space and rear seat flexibility.In conclusion, the 2024 Smart #1 and #3 offer a compelling package for those seeking a distinctive electric SUV experience. Their combination of performance, style, and technology make them strong contenders in the premium small EV segment, provided buyers can work with the limited dealer network.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between the Smart #1 and #3?
A: The #1 has a more traditional SUV shape with better rear headroom and a sliding rear seat, while the #3 has a sportier, coupe-like design with slightly lower suspension.
How extensive is the Smart dealer network in Australia?
A: Currently, Smart vehicles are only sold through three dealerships in Brisbane, Sydney, and Melbourne.
What is the warranty coverage for the Smart #1 and #3?
A: Smart offers a five-year/150,000km warranty on these models.
Are there plans to expand the Smart dealer network in Australia?
A: As of now, there are no announced plans to expand beyond the three current locations.
How does the performance of the Brabus versions compare to other electric SUVs?
A: The Brabus variants offer some of the quickest acceleration times in their class, with 0-100km/h times under 4 seconds.
